10 Best Books Like Night in the City
If you loved Night in the City by Michael McGarrity, here are the most similar books our readers recommend.
Quick Answer
The best books like Night in the City are:
- 1Mad Honey by Jodi Picoult and Jennifer Finney Boylan0
- 2Into the Water by Paula Hawkins4.3
- 3Pony Confidential by Christina Lynch4.4
- 4The Little Liar by Mitch Albom0
- 5The Man Who Died Twice by Richard Osman4.6#2
- 6Murder at Gulls Nest by Jess Kidd4.3
- 7When Will There be Good News? by Kate Atkinson4.4#3
- 8One Good Turn by Kate Atkinson4.2#2
- 9The Madness of Crowds by Louise Penny0
- 10Smoke and Embers by John Lawton4.4

When Korean War veteran and assistant district attorney Sam Monroe discovers his former lover murdered with his own dog tags around her neck, he becomes the prime suspect and must go underground to clear his name. Racing against time as police close in and circumstantial evidence mounts, Sam delves into the victim's shadowy past involving crime families and dark secrets. Set in gritty 1950s New York, this classic noir follows a desperate man fighting to prove his innocence before becoming the next victim.
We may earn a small commission from purchases made through these links at no extra cost to you.
Detailed Recommendations

The Man Who Died Twice
Thursday Murder Club #2 (works standalone)by Richard Osman
Why you'll love it:
This mystery shares a warm and clever tone that will resonate with Night in the City fans.

When Will There be Good News?
Jackson Brodie #3 (works standalone)by Kate Atkinson
Why you'll love it:
This mystery shares a darkly hopeful tone that will resonate with Night in the City fans.

One Good Turn
Jackson Brodie #2 (works standalone)by Kate Atkinson
Why you'll love it:
This mystery shares a darkly comic tone that will resonate with Night in the City fans.
Quick Comparison: Books Like Night in the City
| Book | Author | Rating | Year | Pages | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mad Honey | Jodi Picoult and Jennifer Finney Boylan | 0 | — | — | Closest match |
| Into the Water | Paula Hawkins | 4.3 | 2017 | 386 | Similar vibes |
| Pony Confidential | Christina Lynch | 4.4 | 2024 | 384 | Similar vibes |
| The Little Liar | Mitch Albom | 0 | — | — | Similar vibes |
| The Man Who Died Twice | Richard Osman | 4.6 | 2022 | 400 | Similar vibes |
| Murder at Gulls Nest | Jess Kidd | 4.3 | 2026 | 336 | Similar vibes |
| When Will There be Good News? | Kate Atkinson | 4.4 | 2008 | 352 | Similar vibes |
| One Good Turn | Kate Atkinson | 4.2 | 2006 | 396 | Similar vibes |
| The Madness of Crowds | Louise Penny | 0 | — | — | Similar vibes |
| Smoke and Embers | John Lawton | 4.4 | 2025 | 416 | Similar vibes |
Authors Who Write Like Michael McGarrity
If you enjoy Michael McGarrity's writing style, explore these similar authors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What books are most similar to Night in the City?
The most similar books to Night in the City are Mad Honey, Into the Water, Pony Confidential.
What should I read after Night in the City?
After finishing Night in the City, readers most commonly pick up Mad Honey next.
Who writes books like Michael McGarrity?
Authors similar to Michael McGarrity include Dennis Lehane.
What genre is Night in the City?
Night in the City is a Mystery novel by Michael McGarrity, published in 2025.
How long is Night in the City?
Night in the City is 272 pages long.
About Night in the City
Accused of the murder of his former lover, Korean War veteran Sam Monroe is forced to abandon his job as an assistant district attorney and fight to clear his name.Sam Monroe thought his steamy love affair with Manhattan socialite Laura Nielson was dead and buried, but when she didn’t show up after unexpectedly calling him late at night and asking to meet, he decides to investigate. He finds her naked on her penthouse balcony, strangled, his dog tags wrapped around her neck. With a bull’s-eye on his back as the prime suspect, Sam begins a search for the killer that reveals Laura’s involvement with several men, some with ties to a well-known crime family.As circumstantial evidence mounts against him, the cops close in, especially a heavy-handed rogue patrolman carrying a grudge against Sam and looking for serious payback. Forced to operate in the shadows, he relies on the unofficial help of several coworkers in the DA’s office and Debora Jean Ryan, a private investigator who offers to assist but has an agenda that she refuses to disclose. As they probe Laura’s past looking for clues, they must also figure out Laura’s mysterious trip out west, the death of a young man in New Jersey during her childhood, and who is making attempts on his life.From the crime-ridden precincts of Lower Manhattan, the mean streets of Spanish Harlem, and the lofty mansions along Millionaires’ Row, Night in the City is classic crime noir fiction at its best that wonderfully evokes the vibrant world of 1950s New York. Michael McGarrity again proves himself to be one of the most accomplished writers of mysteries working today.






